Sell & consign
We publish how we buy and how consignment works so you know the deal before you walk in.
Selling to us
We base every offer on current market value, adjusted for what it costs us to resell the item. That includes platform fees and shipping on anything we sell online. In-case items are priced off the market comp directly.
You always get the offer explained, with the comp in front of you.
Take cash, or take store credit and get more. Credit is typically 15 percentage points higher than the cash offer on most items.
Cash payouts are limited to $500 per customer and $1,500 per day. Larger payouts are made by check or ACH.
We treat a trade as a purchase paid in merchandise. Your items are valued at the store-credit rate, and you pay the difference on anything you take from the case.
We don’t do straight-across swaps.
We buy Tuesday through Friday only. If you come in on a weekend with something to sell, we’ll set an appointment for the next buy window instead of rushing a quote.
Have a big collection? Tell us about it and we’ll schedule time.
Consignment
For higher-value pieces, consignment can net you more than a straight sale. We list it, market it, sell it and pay you. You never pay a listing, photo or handling fee.
When an item sells, the actual platform fee for that sale comes off the top first (if it sold online). Then our commission is taken from what’s left:
| Amount after fees | Our commission |
|---|---|
| Under $600 | 30% |
| $600 or more | 25% |
Shipping, packaging and insurance come out of our share. Not yours.
In our store case, eBay, TCGplayer, Whatnot live shows and Facebook Marketplace (local pickup, closed at our counter).
Choose cash, check or ACH. Or choose store credit and get an extra 10% of your net payout.
| Sold in-store for | Our commission | You receive | Or in store credit |
|---|---|---|---|
| $500 | 30% = $150 | $350 | $385 |
| $1,000 | 25% = $250 | $750 | $825 |
Online sales have the platform’s actual fee deducted before commission is calculated. You’ll see the exact numbers on your payout receipt.
New consignors get a sign-in link from us by text or email after their first drop-off.
Questions
Not during buy hours, Tuesday through Friday. For large collections, an appointment lets us set aside the time to do it right.
Credit stays in the shop and keeps inventory moving, so we can afford to pay more for it.
Bring it in or send a request with photos. We price off recent comparable sales, and we’ll show you the comp.
It depends on the item and where it sells best. We’ll tell you the plan up front and update you when it sells.
Yes. The consignor portal shows every item, its price and status, each sale with the fee and commission, and your payouts. We send you a sign-in link after your first drop-off.
You’re never charged for listing or handling. We’ll talk about adjusting the price or picking it up.